Privatizing the Province of Mankind: How Property Rights Can Unleash the Commercial Space Sector
Outer space is a vacuum—devoid of life, borders, and terrestrial statutes. Fueled by geopolitical competition and an influx of private capital, however, the cadence of launch attempts—324 in 2025, up from 259 the year prior—is accelerating. Global private investment grew 48% over that same period, topping $12 billion. And this growth has fostered a suite of emerging applications, including space resource extraction, where spacecraft collect valuable raw materials from asteroids for use on Earth, and eventually, in space. Today, private companies such as AstroForge and SpaceX are leading the nascent space mining industry. Yet these firms are incentivized to rapidly grab resources under current international and domestic space law, which fails to provide resource collectors with the legal certainty necessary for long-term investments. Establishing a tradeable-permit scheme for space resources, one that caps extraction and creates transferable title enforced through commercial contracts and domestic law, can better align the incentives of private firms to sustainably invest in space mining and the broader space economy.
Existing Space Resource Governance
Traditionally, space governance has been handled internationally, underpinned by the United Nations’ 1967 Outer Space Treaty (OST). At the height of the Space Race, the OST sought to establish norms for global cooperation in space science and exploration and to preserve celestial objects as the “province of all mankind.” Article II prohibits “national appropriation” of the Moon and other bodies, including asteroids, by claims of sovereignty. Similarly, the 1984 UN Moon Treaty declares the Moon as the “common heritage of mankind” and expressly bars ownership claims by any state, non-government entity, or individual over lunar resources.
Baked into these norms was the presumption that governments, not private companies, would lead space exploration. NASA’s Apollo Program, which successfully landed the first humans on the Moon, peaked at 4.4% of the total federal budget in 1966. Today, 4.4% of the U.S. federal budget is $308 billion, a spending level far surpassing the total valuation of most commercial space companies. Space was simply too costly for any entity besides a national government. The framers of these treaties, therefore, assumed that any celestial dispute would likely involve sovereigns and be resolved internationally.
In 2015, Congress recognized that to facilitate increased investment in the American private space sector, it needed to foster “stable and predictable regulatory conditions” for commercial space firms. That year, it passed the Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act (CSLCA), which entitled U.S. citizens to “possess, own, […] and sell” all space resources “obtained” commercially. Space technologies, particularly private launch capabilities, meanwhile, were advancing rapidly. Less than a month after the CSLCA’s passage, SpaceX landed its Falcon 9 reusable rocket for the first time. The cost of launching a kilogram of mass into orbit, once $54,500, fell to just $2,720 with the Falcon 9, opening humanity’s final frontier to startups and Fortune 500 companies alike.
However, because the CSLCA confers title only after a resource is “obtained” by capture, it encourages private firms to grab resources to receive legal protection. This process, which risks crowding out long-term investment in space resource collection, is explored more in the following section.
Regulating to Align Incentives for Private Space Resource Collection
Multiple American companies today are pursuing the capability to collect and commoditize space resources. AstroForge aims to “[bring] space resources into Earth’s supply chain,” supplementing valuable terrestrial metal stocks. Relying on the CSLCA, the company plans to sell collected resources to facilitate “a more sustainable future.” AstroForge’s first deep-space mission, nicknamed “Odin,” launched in February 2025 and cost just $3.5 million to develop. Mission two, called “DeepSpace-2,” intends to launch and rendezvous with an asteroid in 2027.
While AstroForge has raised $55 million in venture capital financing, SpaceX went public with a valuation of over $1.7 trillion. In its pre-IPO S-1 filing, SpaceX described plans to “pursue asteroid mining operations” in an effort to lower the costs of raw materials supplied to future space-based activities. SpaceX also represents a major asset to the U.S. government in Washington’s ongoing efforts to reduce dependence on Chinese-supplied critical minerals. This national security imperative is also likely to drive public and private investment in deep-space mining capabilities, benefiting both startups and established firms.
However, while the CSLCA provides American firms of all sizes title to space resources, that title vests — and thus is only enforceable — after resources are “obtained.” The statute imposes no enforceable extraction caps, which incentivizes more capable early entrants like SpaceX to grab resources to legally protect their investments. By attempting to monopolize resources, these first movers erect barriers to market entry for newer and smaller competitors, likely reducing overall investment in the broader commercial space economy. National regulations that do cap extraction could unlock an estimated $2 trillion in the global space economy by 2040.
Tradeable permits for space resources, which provide space resource collectors with an asset—the permit—that can be sold or acquired by contract, would realign the incentives held by private entities. Each permit would entitle its holder to extract a set allotment, potentially from a specified stock on a particular asteroid. The easy transferability of each permit would allow firms of different sizes to possess as many as they could economically utilize. Violations of the scheme, such as overextraction or extraction of another firm’s assigned stock, could be enforced in American courts under laws proscribing theft and civil property damage.
Tradeable permit schemes have been successfully employed to combat private resource grabs in unregulated commercial fishing, where individual private actors attempt to maximize profits from a common good, leading to overfishing and billions in reduced long-term profits. To solve the “Tragedy of the Commons,” regulators capped market-wide harvests and introduced tradeable permits apportioned to fishers, which were sold and acquired by contract and protected by law. These catch-share programs have curbed overfishing while increasing profitability. In 2010, of the eighteen active catch-share programs in the U.S., thirteen saw catch prices rise, increasing profits by millions. Fishery stocks, meanwhile, reached seventeen-year highs.
Unlike in fisheries, however, depletion of a limited resource is not a concern in space. It is estimated that the accessible mining volume on asteroids, in the main asteroid belt alone, exceeds the combined volume on the Moon, Mars, and Mercury, with some asteroids composed of 30–60% metal. If the supply of valuable space resources is that vast, an extraction cap would serve only to artificially inflate material prices on Earth, not prevent resource grabs. In that scenario, assigning tradeable permits for specific resource sites would more effectively enable permit holders to collect resources over time, much like modern mining leases. Even if the mechanisms of the scheme change, however, the underlying need to provide firms with legal certainty to enforce their private resource allocations remains crucial to fostering sustained investment in space resource collection.
Conclusion
Space resource collection is an emerging industry, with capital investments from both space-oriented startups and large companies. International space treaties, however, fail to provide these private actors with the legal certainty they need to invest in long-term space mining capabilities. In turn, private space resource collectors are incentivized to monopolize resource stocks and crowd out competition, a threat exacerbated by the CSLCA’s capture-based ownership regime. By establishing regulatory frameworks like tradeable permits, enforceable under contract in American courts, lawmakers can effectively commoditize valuable space resources, driving further investment in the space economy and unlocking the potential of humanity’s final frontier.
Will Erens
GLTR Staff Editor; J.D. Candidate, Georgetown University Law Center (2028); B.S., Political Economy, University of Southern California (2025).